Welcome all to playoff time! Luckily for us here in D3land, we have an extra round of games mid week. Here is a plain and simple pick’em for these first round games. We have some really great match ups for the first round as most teams have faced similar opponents and in two cases each other during the regular season. It’s going to get real tricky to pick these games as the playoffs go on. In my mind there are 6-7 teams that could easily take the crown this season! But first they’ll have to make it to Foxboro where I will take the trophy from the winning team and parade around the parking lots like I just won myself!
Springfield (11-6) vs Mount Ida (13-6)
Both teams are lead by strong offensive units. They both beat Babson, however Mount Ida only won 8-7 where Springfield topped them 22-6. And they both lost to Amherst but Springfields was just a wee bit closer. Mount Ida has an offense that can put up huge numbers in a run and gun game. If Springfield isn’t sharp this one could be the shocker of the D3 playoffs.
Prediction: Mount Ida - 13-12 OT
St. Lawrence (12-3) vs Nazareth (11-6)
Earlier this season, St. Lawrence topped Naz 15-10. Both teams beat Oswego handidly yet lost by large margins to Cortland. Naz seems to have a better offense from the numbers and the tilt moves to St. Lawrence on the defensive side. It should be a battle to see who moves on to the next round. The game against each other was pretty early on and both teams have gotten better along the way. It should come down to coaching.
Prediction: St. Lawrence - 12-10
US Merchant Marine 11-5 vs Eastern Conn. St. (14-3)
No common opponents played in 2009. UMM has played 3 playoff teams going 1-2 (beat FDU-Florham 7-6 and lost to Wesleyan and W&L). ECS has faced 3 playoff teams also going 1-2 (Win over Mt Ida 14-7 and losses to Salisbury and Montclair St). ECS has just a tad more fire power and will cruise to the win.
Prediction: Eastern Conn. St. - 13-8
Cabrini (14-3) vs Montclair St. (13-4)
Both teams dominated in weak conferences but made up for it with tough out of conference schedules. No opponents in common. Monclair St. has faced two playoff teams with losses to both Cortland and Wesleyan. Cabrini has faced 4 playoff teams going 2-2 (Wins over Haverford and FDU-Florham and losses to Gettysburg and Roanoke). Look for Cabrini’s strong offense to run away with this one.
Prediction: Cabrini - 16-8
Denision (12-2) vs OWU (10-4)
Due to travel, OWU and Denison get to meet for a 2nd time this season after a Denison TKO in the 1st meeting. Common opponents; OWU lost to Lynchburg who Denison crushed, both defeated Oberlin, Adrian, Colorado College, Kenyon, Wooster, Wittenburg and Mount St Joseph. Denison seems to be the better squad this season out in Ohio.
Preditcion: Denison 15-10
W&L (15-3) vs FDU-Florham (13-4)
The Generals are coming out of the South’s toughest division in 2009. Common opponents faced; US Merchant Marines beat FDU and lost to W&L, both beat Desales. FDU is 0-3 against playoff teams (Cabrini, US Merchant Marines and Haverford). W&L has played 4 playoff team games and are 2-2 with wins over US Merchant Marines and Roanoke in the ODAC finals and losses to Roanoke and Middlebury. This will be a warm-up for W&L for the following weekend where they will see Gettysburg.
Prediction: W&L 15-6
Here’s what the 2nd RD games would look like based on my 1st Rd picks. I will update these after the first round of games if any of my picks are in correct.
*Cortland St. (15-2) vs Mount Ida (13-6)
Tufts (13-4) vs WNE. (16-2)
*Middlebury (13-2) vs St. Lawrence (12-3)
*Wesleyan (CT) (14-3) vs Eastern Conn. St. (14-3)
*Stevenson (15-1) vs Cabrini (14-3)
*Haverford (13-3) vs Salisbury (15-3)
*Roanoke (17-1) vs Denison (12-2)
*Gettysburg (13-3) vs W&L (15-3)